Guided by Grace: 

A Catholic Woman’s Journey to Enter Religious Life Amid Immigration Challenges

Taking a deep breath, Tabu* pressed the buzzer on the convent door and waited. She fidgeted with her bag nervously. After a minute the door opened and a middle-aged woman with a soft, warm smile appeared.

“Welcome to our community. My name is Sister Marcella Ann. You must be Tabassum?”

“Yes, thank you. You can please call me Tabu.”

Tabu followed Sister Marcella Ann inside and they sat down in a nearby office room across from one another. The walls were adorned with crosses, pictures of the saints, and images of the Sisters in service around the world. Tabu’s rapid heartbeat slowed.

“Well, Tabu, thank you for your interest in our congregation. I serve as vocations director for our order, which I’m happy to tell you more about. But first, I would love to hear a little more about you and what brings you to us today.”

Tabu cleared her throat. Where to start?

“I think I have felt God’s call to become a religious sister all my life,” she began.

Tabu explained about her childhood, how she’d grown up in a predominantly Muslim country in South Asia, in a large and highly devout Catholic family. Her family was very involved in their local parish and close to the community of religious sisters who served at the parish.

She explained how the family was so familiar with these local sisters that she and her siblings treated their convent as a second home, entering and exiting without ringing the bell, spending time accompanying the sisters in their work among the parishioners and the local poor, and in their prayer.

Tabu’s childhood memories were full of the cheerful, soft voices of the sisters; the melodic sounds of their prayers; the way they exuded peace, generosity, and faith; the way their presence shaped her family life, helping her and her siblings learn the importance of service to the poor, courage, gentleness, strength, and perseverance in trial.

Following the example of these sisters, she regularly tutored the children of the more impoverished families in her community. When Tabu’s elder sister began working in youth ministry, Tabu, a teenager, shadowed her, teaching catechism and working with the local youth in social justice and religious education. She felt most at home and alive in this context — serving, giving, immersing herself in caring for others.

Her own siblings had all settled into different jobs and vocations, some getting married and starting families. Tabu had finished her education and taken various jobs, several that took her overseas. But she had felt restless, unsettled.

When she brought these feelings to God, in prayer and reflection, she felt a yearning in her heart for the peace of community life that she’d witnessed as a young child among the sisters at her parish – a total commitment of her life to God and a group of other women among whom she could serve and rely on.

Over the course of several years, she had discerned joining a few other communities of Catholic sisters, including several in the United States. None had seemed a good fit. In those years she lost both of her parents, and drifted from place to place, feeling a bit bereft in the world.

She was presently in the United States on a religious visa sponsored by a different congregation, as she considered joining their community, but had been there for several months before realizing it wasn’t the right fit for her. Just recently, her close friend, Sister Rose, who had been the religious education director at her parish back home, had strongly suggested she reach out to this particular congregation of sisters, whom she was visiting today, and who were located in the northeastern United States.

“These Sisters share your heart for the poor, for unity with God and neighbor,” she had told Tabu. “Their mission is your mission.”

“So,” Tabu concluded to Sister Marcella Ann, “I feel God has led me to you, to come and learn about your community.”

Sister Marcella Ann’s smile was warm and genuine.

“Tabu, what a beautiful story. I will make some calls to learn more about your background. The next step will be a mutual discernment, where you spend time with us so you can learn about our community, we can learn about you, and we will pray for God’s guidance over whether you are called to join us in our life and mission.”

Tabu nodded her consent, and the two women parted. Tabu left the convent feeling lighter, more hopeful. Could this be where she belonged?

In the following week, Sister Marcella Ann made several phone calls to the references Tabu had left — to her pastor, former employers, and other communities she’d discerned with.

When she hung up the phone from her last call, she sat still and reflected. Each of Tabu’s contacts had confirmed the impression Sister Marcella Ann had had of Tabu: a woman who exuded warmth and earnestness, whose heart burned for love of God and neighbor, and who was equally committed to a life of service and community.

With a gentle knock, her superior, Sister Madeline, entered the office.

“Well?” said Sister Madeline. “What do you think?” She looked intently at Sister Marcella Ann. It was no small thing to invite someone to come discern with the community — an investment of time, attention, and resources.

“She sounds like one of us.”

Finding a Home With the Sisters: 2 years Later

Tabu sat at a table surrounded by women who were forty to fifty years her senior. She was gently helping Sr. Diane, the 84-year-old woman to her left, cut her pork chop into bites. To her right, Sr. Judith, a 90-year-old, was humming to herself and staring into the distance. It was a seemingly mundane moment — but Tabu was aware of feeling supremely peaceful and happy.

That morning, she had woken up in her room, gone down to say morning prayers with the younger and more active sisters, eaten breakfast, and then had spent the rest of the morning on the Memory Care floor, where she was now assigned.

When she was first assigned to work with the elderly sisters at the convent, she felt a little awkward and nervous among them, not knowing how to interact with them or help with their needs.

But quickly the elderly sisters had grown fond of her, with her warm smile and playful manner, and she in turn had come to love them and see who they were: powerful women of faith with enormous histories of self-sacrifice and service behind them.

“I think the Holy Spirit is teaching me how to love them,” Tabu told Sister Marcella Ann.

There was Sister Angela, who had been a school principal and had championed racial integration in the local school system. There was Sister Margaret, who had been a leading social worker among inner city impoverished families in the 70s, speaking out against drug policy and the failures of social welfare. Now these women were elderly, in need of intense caregiving, but their forceful personalities and compassion shone through.

They welcomed her into their lives, and she came to know their particular needs – she helped Sister Angela take her medicine each morning, and in the afternoons pushed various sisters’ wheelchairs around the garden. In the evenings she watched Jeopardy with Sister Margaret, who knew every answer. She moved quietly and lovingly among the sisters, assisting them in everyday tasks.

In her spare time, at the vocation director’s instruction, Tabu read books about the history of the sisters and their spirituality. She learned about how the Sisters, since their founding, had been at the forefront of the movement to connect social concerns and the Catholic faith. This resonated deeply with Tabu; since her youth she had known that loving God meant serving one’s neighbor.

Here among the sisters, incredible lives of self-sacrifice were the norm; the sisters challenged one another to become better people, and they supported one another through the various hardships that came with giving one’s life away for the sake of serving others. The more time Tabu spent among them, the more she wanted to become part of the community.

“Tabu?” One of the other sisters who was helping on the Memory Care floor called out to her.

“Sisters Madeline and Marcella Ann would like to speak with you in the conference room now.”

Tabu felt a chill run through her. This meeting, which she’d anticipated, was about her immigration case. She moved through the hallways of the convent and noticed how beloved and familiar each room was – the chapel, the library, the cafeteria. For the first time since her childhood, this place felt like home.

She entered the conference room, where she greeted Sister Madeline, who was provincial, or leader of the congregation, and Sister Marcella Ann. She looked up and saw projected on the screen that her immigration lawyer, Graciela Mateo, from a law organization called CLINIC, was present via video call. They all greeted her warmly, but the formality of the meeting made nerves bubble in her stomach.

“Tabu, we want to begin by saying how grateful we are for your presence in our community,” said Sister Madeline. “In these years of mutual discernment, it has become clear to us that God is calling you to be here with us. What we are about to discuss about your immigration case does not change that.”

Graciela, her attorney, gently began to explain the situation. The Sisters were eager to start her process to apply for permanent U.S. residency. When CLINIC had taken on her immigration case, they had learned that, unfortunately, the previous U.S. religious congregation that Tabu had discerned with had filed her paperwork for an R-1 visa incorrectly. This meant that Tabu would have to leave the United States to apply for an R-1 religious worker visa from abroad. Taking this step was essential so that she could apply for permanent residency. 

Tabu felt horror wash over her, and tears filled her eyes. She had to leave? To return to her country of origin? She had watched numerous people throughout her life apply for U.S. visas while in her country, with no success. What if she could never come back?

The convent was her home; these sisters were her family. God was so clearly calling her here. Why was this happening?

The sisters saw her emotion and jumped in.

“Tabu, don’t be afraid. We will get you back. It is just a temporary separation. God will guide.”

Graciela, too, warmly assured her that they would work rapidly to get her application processed. In the fog of her emotion, Tabu heard their words of comfort. But in that moment, she could only feel grief and desolation.

At the Embassy

Tabu’s hands shook as she handed over the U.S. visa paperwork to the man sitting behind the glass. She was at the U.S. embassy in her home country, and in a few moments, she would learn if she had been granted a religious worker visa to return to the Sisters’ convent in the United States.

She watched him shuffle through her paperwork. In her lap she carried an enormous binder with all the legal paperwork and documents she had assembled over the last few months, with the help of her attorney at CLINIC, Graciela, and the Sisters’ congregation.

It had been fifty days since she’d left the convent and returned to her native country. Fifty long days, that had sometimes felt like 50 years. She had cherished this opportunity to visit her family, as she loved them dearly, and they were so good to her, but being here — away from the rhythm and culture of the convent, back in the bustle of this sprawling, hot city, without work to employ her or people to accompany her — she’d felt extremely homesick for the convent. Without a doubt, the convent had become her home.

The officer asked her a series of questions, which she answered with a shaking voice. At the end of the interview, he handed her a blue piece of paper. Graciela had told her the blue paper would mean she had received a visa, but she needed to be sure.

“I have been granted a visa?”

“Yes,” the officer replied curtly.

Joy flooded her heart. She flew down the stairs of the embassy and into the arms of her youngest sister, who had been waiting outside the gates praying a rosary for her throughout the interview. They rejoiced, with tears and laughter. Tabu was going home!

Back at the house, Tabu and her sisters prostrated themselves in prayer, bowed low on the ground in the style typical of their culture, thanking God for this immense blessing.

Dancing With Joy

The day Tabu returned to the Sisters’ convent in the United States, she walked into the cafeteria to a storm of applause. The sisters gathered to welcome her back warmly.

“Tabu, how we missed you!”

“We have prayed for you every day.”

Tabu was overcome with happiness to be home. “I feel so loved by this community,” she told Sister Marcella Ann.

Tabu jumped back into her daily rhythms and responsibilities with enthusiasm. She came up with new activities for the elderly sisters, and even began introducing them to her South Asian culture, including through cooking. To the wonder of the senior leadership of the congregation, the elderly sisters – mostly of Irish, German, or Italian descent — loved the South Asian flavors and the smells that would waft through the hallways when it was Tabu’s turn to cook.

One afternoon, in a burst of energy and creativity, Tabu decided the elderly sisters could use a change of pace. She gathered them out in the courtyard of the Convent, wheeling them out one by one. Then, she pulled out a boom box and began playing music — first old-timey show tunes that the sisters would recognize, and then she began playing South Asian music, some of her favorites.

“We’re going to have a dance party!” Tabu exclaimed, laughing.

The elderly sisters, taken aback at first, couldn’t help but smile when Tabu began dancing among them, moving her arms gracefully in the style of her culture. Then a few of them began to join her, waving their arms, and then several sisters even got out of their wheelchairs to move about to the rhythm of the music.

Soon, it was a full-on event. Seeing the commotion, the food service coordinator organized ice cream to be brought out. Sister Madeline, from her office on the first floor, heard the music and laughter and came to investigate. She joined Sister Marcella Ann in watching the scene from the corner of the courtyard.

“How they missed her when she was gone!” said Sister Marcella Ann. “Her joy is infectious. They have captured her heart, and she has captured theirs.”

Leaving for Canada, 2.5 years later

It was Christmas Eve, and Tabu was boarding the last flight bound for Canada.

Over 4000 flights between the U.S. and Canada had just been cancelled due to the closure of the borders in the wake of a surge in the COVID-19 pandemic. But somehow, providentially, both to her sadness and relief, Tabu was still leaving.

As the plane took off from the ground, Tabu felt tears welling up beneath her eyelids. She took off the N-95 mask that was tight against her face to wipe them away. How was it that she was being forced to leave her community — her family — again? And this time for an entire year? It felt like her heart was breaking.

A few months prior, in the midst of a thriving life in community with the Sisters, where she was progressing in her formation and in commitment to the congregation, she had been called down to a meeting with Sisters Marcella Ann and Madeline once again. Just like before, Graciela was on a video call. Tabu’s heart had been racing.

As gently as they could, they once again told her that they had hit a snag with her immigration case. They had started the process to petition for her permanent residency (green card) over two years ago, but there were significant backlogs in U.S. visa processing at government agencies during the COVID-19 pandemic. Now, the 2.5-year time limit for her temporary religious worker (R-1) visa had run out, despite the extension they had filed for. She had to leave the United States for at least one year in order to continue the process.

Tears had poured down Tabu’s face, but the sisters had quickly jumped in to say that they’d worked out a plan for how to get her back.

“Tabu, you will come back, please trust us and trust God.”

The sisters explained that they had arranged for her to go to Canada, to stay with another congregation of Sisters with a similar mission and history, for at least one year. They had arranged her Canadian work visa and everything. Unfortunately, she would have to leave before the end of the year.

Tabu had nodded, appreciating the care they had put into providing her with a plan before telling her this news. But still, she felt devastated at the idea of picking up her life here — so happy, so full — and moving to an unknown community for a year.

Later that day, when she arrived at the Sisters’ convent in Canada, she was greeted warmly by one of its leaders, Sister Rosemary. On their drive back to the convent, Sister Rosemary asked about Tabu’s community in the United States, and inquired how the Sisters there were handling the COVID-19 pandemic.

Tabu shared about the sisters she worked with and loved, and how hard it had been to watch the convent go into lockdown over the last year, and the subsequent isolation the elderly sisters had faced in particular. Sister Rosemary agreed that the past year had been very difficult for her congregation as well, what with the fragile health of so many elderly sisters. The congregation had just been forced to go back into lockdown with the recent COVID surge.

The following day, on Christmas, Tabu awoke to find notes and gifts from the sisters slipped under the door of her room. Tears filled her eyes as she read the notes:

“We are so glad you are here!”

“You are our Christmas present!”

Tabu had shared with Sister Rosemary that during the previous Christmas, in the last COVID lockdown, the U.S. Sisters had eaten Christmas dinner in the doorways outside of their rooms, so that they were six feet apart but still able to converse. Inspired by this idea, Sister Rosemary organized Christmas dinner this way for the Canadian sisters.

Talking and laughing with the sisters in the hallway at Christmas dinner, Tabu’s heavy heart began to lighten. This was not home, but it was like staying with relatives. She could find a temporary home here.

Faith Amid Uncertainty

After evening prayers, Tabu lingered in chapel at the Sisters’ convent back in the United States. Her heart was full of mixed emotions, thoughts buzzing through her mind, and she needed to bring them to God.

It had now been several months since she had returned to the United States from her year-long stay with the other Sisters congregation in Canada. She had been overjoyed to return home to the Sisters here, and the community had been thrilled to welcome her back. She’d resumed her former duties among the elderly sisters eagerly, as well as her spiritual formation and preparation to permanently join the community.

But there were heavy things weighing on her as well. In the year away, she had grown close to the sisters in Canada, particularly the elderly sisters she’d cared for there. She asked God why she had to go through the pain of learning to love a new community only to leave them again.

In addition, upon returning here, she saw there were changes among the elderly sisters — some passed away, some whose health had deteriorated. Her rhythms of care among them had faded and needed to be re-learned and reestablished. The year away, while blessed in many ways, was a disruption.

And, weighing on her most of all: just this morning, she had met with Graciela and Sisters Marcella Ann and Madeline about her immigration case. Graciela, with tears in her eyes herself, had broken very hard news to Tabu. The U.S. government had changed its policies and were now only processing applications for permanent residency with a filing date before September 2018. Tabu’s had been filed after that, so hers was indefinitely on hold — and her R-1 visa status of 2.5 years might run out again before the government could process her permanent resident application.

It was possible she would have to leave the country — for a third time. After the call, the sisters sat with Tabu and helped her process the news.

“I have never felt like an outsider here in the United States, here among you all…but this immigration process is making me feel like one,” she told Sister Marcella Ann. “It’s like people in the government assume I am coming here for the sake of immigrating alone. I wish they could understand that I’m not coming merely to immigrate – I am coming for a vocation.”

For the next few years, until policies changed, Tabu would be living in a cloud of uncertainty. But here, in the chapel, she remembered how God had been with her every step of the way — in bringing her here to the Sisters, guiding her in her time in South Asia and in Canada, and animating her joyful work and study in the present.

“God will guide,” She whispered to herself.

She had said “yes” to what she felt was God’s call to join this community and live her life in service to others. She could feel how her faith had been strengthened, crystallized, through these years of trial.

If God was truly calling, there would be a way.

To learn more about CLINIC's Religious Immigration Services, click here. To learn about how you can advocate on behalf of religious workers facing immigration processing delays, click here.

This story was written by Kathleen Kollman Birch, CLINIC staff member, through interviews with Tabu and her religious community.

We want to express our gratitude once again to Michelle Garcia, the artist behind the illustrations that accompany this piece. Michelle Garcia is an illustrator, designer, first generation American and Latina. Learn more about her work here. 

*All names have been changed, except those of CLINIC staff, to protect client privacy during an ongoing immigration case.

**Congregation name removed for the sake of privacy.

CLINIC advocates for humane and just immigration policy. Its network of nonprofit immigration programs — over 450 organizations in 49 states and the District of Columbia — is the largest in the nation.